Fence Guides · Replacement

Replacing an Old Fence in Connecticut: What to Expect

Taking out an old fence is its own job. Here is what tear-out involves, whether old posts can be reused, how disposal works in Connecticut, what it adds to a quote and how to avoid surprises on the day.

By Arrow Fence Inc. · East Hampton, CT · Since 1979 · Last updated October 2026

When a fence is leaning, rotted or simply tired, the question is rarely about the new fence. It is about the old one: who takes it out, where it goes, what happens to the lawn and what that adds to the bill. Tear-out is the least glamorous part of a fence project, and it is often described in a single line on a quote. This guide explains what is actually involved, so that line makes sense and you can plan around it. It is general information about how replacement projects usually go, and the details on your property will depend on the fence, the posts, the soil and your town.

Short answer

Replacing an old fence usually means cutting out the panels, pulling or digging out the posts and footings, hauling the debris away, filling the holes and then building the new fence along the same line or a better one. Expect removal to appear as its own line on the quote, and ask whether disposal is included. Old wood posts are rarely worth reusing, and old fence lumber cannot be burned in Connecticut.

In this guide
  1. What is involved in replacing an old fence?
  2. Repair or replace?
  3. Can old posts be reused?
  4. What removal adds to the cost
  5. Disposal: what happens to the old fence
  6. What to expect on tear-out day
  7. Do you need a permit to replace?
  8. Doing the tear-out yourself
  9. When replacement is the wrong choice
  10. Replacing an old fence: common questions

What is involved in replacing an old fence?

A replacement project has two halves: taking the old fence out and putting the new one in. The first half is often underestimated. In sequence, it usually looks like this.

  1. Confirm what you are removing. Is the fence yours, a neighbor’s or shared? Where is the true property line? See our property line guide before anything comes down.
  2. Clear access. Plants, hoses, lights, dog runs, trampolines and anything attached to the fence need to move.
  3. Cut and remove the fence panels or fabric. Boards and panels come off, and on chain link the fabric is unwound from the posts.
  4. Remove the posts. This is the slow part, especially where posts are set in concrete.
  5. Haul away and dispose of debris. Wood, metal, vinyl and concrete all have different disposal paths.
  6. Fill and level. Old post holes are filled and rough grade is restored.
  7. Set the new line. Posts for the new fence go in, often with some on the old line and some off it.

Where the old fence has to come out before new posts go in, the removal work and the new installation need to be scheduled together. Ask your contractor how they sequence it so the yard is not open longer than necessary. If you have a dog, kids or a pool, that detail matters.

Should you repair the old fence or replace it?

Before you commit to tear-out, make sure replacement is really the right call. A fence with one rotted section or a single heaved post is often worth repairing. A fence with failing posts along most of its length is usually not. Our repair vs replacement guide walks through the signs, and our post depth and frost heave guide explains why posts are often the deciding factor.

A rough rule of thumb: if the posts are sound, you can often replace boards, panels or fabric and keep the structure. If the posts have rotted at ground level, leaned out of line or pulled out of their footings, new boards on bad posts will not hold. Sound posts, rare as they are on a fence that has aged badly, are the one reason to keep a framework.

Can old fence posts be reused?

Sometimes, but less often than homeowners hope. The decision is the contractor’s judgment, and a careful one will tell you honestly.

  • Wood posts are rarely worth reusing. Rot starts at and just below the ground line, where moisture sits, and a post that looks solid from above can be soft at the base. A new fence on soft posts will lean again.
  • Metal posts such as galvanized chain link terminal and line posts can be reused if they are straight, undamaged and sized for the new fence. A new fabric on good posts is a common repair.
  • Aluminum and vinyl posts are part of a manufactured system. They can sometimes be reused with the same system, but a different brand, height or style usually needs new posts.
  • Spacing and height. Old posts may be too far apart, too short or set too shallow for the fence you want. Our post depth guide explains why that matters in Connecticut frost.
  • Gate posts take the most abuse and are the ones most often replaced.

Even when a post could be reused, the new fence may be easier and more solid if you start with fresh posts set where they should be, not where the old ones happened to be.

Natural cedar picket fence with an arched gate in front of a white colonial house and flower garden
A cedar picket fence with an arched gate in front of a colonial house. Illustrative image.

What does removing an old fence add to the cost?

Removal is normally priced separately from the new fence. Our guides give planning ranges, and they differ a little by material and by whether posts are set in concrete:

For a 150-foot fence, those ranges work out to roughly $300 to $1,200 before any special conditions. That is simple arithmetic on published ranges, not a quote. Price goes up with concrete footings, overgrown vines and brush, limited access, steep ground and fences that are tied into stone walls or buildings. Ask whether removal, hauling and disposal fees are all included, and whether any dump or transfer station charges are passed along.

What happens to the old fence?

Where an old fence ends up depends on what it is made of.

Material Typical path Things to know
Wood (cedar, pressure-treated) Hauled to a transfer station, landfill or disposal site, often as construction debris Do not burn. Pre-2003 pressure-treated lumber may contain CCA and should be handled as treated wood waste
Chain link and steel posts Scrap metal recycling Metal is usually accepted at transfer stations or scrap yards; ask about fees
Aluminum Scrap metal recycling Usually valuable scrap; sort from steel
Vinyl Disposal as construction debris unless a local recycler takes it Ask your transfer station what it accepts
Concrete footings Construction debris or crushed Heavy and bulky; this is where costs rise

Because disposal rules differ by town, ask your contractor where the debris is taken and whether the price includes it. If you are doing it yourself, call your town’s transfer station or public works department first, since many have rules on construction debris, permits, fees and treated wood.

Do not burn old fence lumber

Connecticut DEEP says residential open burning is limited to brush with a valid permit and is not allowed to dispose of construction debris. Treated wood and old painted wood can also release harmful smoke. See the DEEP residential open burning page.

Wood from fences painted before 1978 can contain lead paint, so avoid sanding, burning or breaking it up. Ask your contractor and your transfer station how they handle it.

Want a firm number for your property?

Request an EstimateCall (860) 267-6636

What should you expect on tear-out day?

  • Noise, trucks and a bare line. Cutting, pulling and loading are noisy. Expect a truck or trailer on the lawn and a few days where the fence line looks rough.
  • Lawn and bed damage. Equipment and foot traffic compact soil and flatten plants near the fence. Move plants you care about and ask what repair is included.
  • Surprises underground. Old posts may be set in large concrete footings. Roots, rocks and buried wire from old dog runs turn up. Call before you dig for new posts; see our Call Before You Dig guide. Ask whether the marking service covers any digging done for removal.
  • Gates and access. If the fence closes off an access point, plan for people, pets and deliveries while the line is open.
  • Neighbor contact. Even if the fence is yours, tell the neighbor the day it comes down. If it is a shared fence, get agreement first. Connecticut’s fence statutes in Chapter 823 cover division fences, and a written agreement beats relying on them.

Weather matters too. Removing posts in saturated spring ground makes a mess, and frozen ground makes removal slow. Our best time to install guide explains how the seasons change the work.

Do you need a permit to replace a fence?

It depends on the town. Some treat a like-for-like replacement of an existing fence differently from a new fence, and some do not. Height, location, materials and pools can all change the answer. Check with your building or zoning office before work begins, and read our fence permit guide for the questions to ask. If your property is near a brook or wetland, also read our guide to fences near wetlands.

The new fence also does not have to match the old one. A replacement is a good time to reconsider height, material and gate locations. Our guide to aluminum vs vinyl and our wood vs vinyl cost comparison may help you choose.

Can you remove the old fence yourself?

You can, and some homeowners do to save the removal line. It is a real job. Sections are heavy and full of nails or screws, and old wood splinters badly. Posts in concrete can be very heavy and hard to extract without a jack or a puller. Cutting metal fabric and wire has its own hazards, and you will need a way to haul the debris and a legal place to take it. The safest split is often to remove boards or panels yourself and leave the posts to the contractor, or to hand over the whole job. If you do it yourself, wear gloves and eye protection, watch for buried utilities and ask your town about disposal.

If you are working with a contractor, ask for the removal in writing. Our guide to what to ask your fence contractor has more items to include.

When is replacing the whole fence the wrong choice?

Replacement is not always the right answer.

  • The fence is not yours. Do not remove a shared or neighbor’s fence without agreement.
  • The posts are sound. A new face on good posts may be all you need.
  • You are about to sell. Repairs and a cleanup may be a better use of money than a new fence.
  • The line is in doubt. Resolve the survey question first.
  • It is the wrong season. Waiting a few weeks for firm, thawed ground can save time and lawn damage.

If you are in East Hampton, Middletown or the Farmington Valley, our East Hampton, Middletown and Avon pages show where we work, and our gallery has finished fences.

Replacing an old fence: common questions

How much does it cost to remove an old fence in Connecticut?

Our guides cite roughly $2 to $8 per linear foot for removal and disposal, depending on material and whether posts are set in concrete. A 150-foot fence is therefore about $300 to $1,200 before special conditions. Those are planning ranges, not quotes, so ask each contractor to list removal and disposal separately.

Can I reuse my old fence posts?

Sometimes. Wood posts are rarely worth reusing because they rot at the ground line, even when they look solid above it. Straight, undamaged metal posts can be reused with new chain link fabric. Aluminum and vinyl posts usually belong to a specific system. Spacing, height and depth also matter, so new posts are often better.

Who disposes of the old fence, me or the contractor?

Either, depending on the quote. Many contractors include removal and haul-away as a separate line item. Ask whether disposal and any transfer station fees are included. If you do it yourself, call your town’s transfer station or public works office first, since rules on construction debris and treated wood differ by town.

Can I burn my old wooden fence in Connecticut?

No. DEEP says residential open burning is limited to brush with a valid permit and is not allowed for disposing of construction debris. Treated and painted wood can also release harmful smoke. Take old fence lumber to a transfer station or have your contractor haul it away.

Is the old pressure-treated wood safe to handle?

Wear gloves and a dust mask when cutting it. Residential lumber treated with CCA was phased out around 2003, so older fences may contain arsenic and should be handled as treated wood waste, not burned or composted. Fences painted before 1978 can also have lead paint. Ask your transfer station about disposal.

Do I need a permit to replace a fence in Connecticut?

Permit rules are set by each town. Some treat like-for-like replacement of an existing fence differently from a new one, and height, location and pool rules can change the answer. Call your building or zoning office before work starts and get the answer in writing.

How long does it take to remove an old fence?

It depends on the length, the material, the footings and access. A short wood fence on small posts can come out quickly, while a long run with concrete footings takes much longer. Ask your contractor how removal and installation will be sequenced and what that means for your yard.

Planning a replacement fence?

We will look at what is there, tell you honestly whether it needs replacing or repair and put removal, disposal and the new fence in one written quote. Fabricated in our East Hampton shop and installed by our own crews.

CT Home Improvement Contractor Reg. HIC.0537503